Allosaurus: Butcher of the Jurassic

Image Credit: Noelle K. Moser. Allosaurus: Houston Museum of Natural History

One-hundred and fifty million years ago, long before T-Rex reigned as the tyrant king of the dinosaurs, another fearsome theropod ruled the land his name, Allosaurus (AL-oh-SORE-us) Fragilis. Spanning a dynasty from 150 million to 144 million years ago during the late Jurassic period, Allosaurus is famous from the Cleveland-Lloyd Quarry in Utah, part of the Morrison Formation and one of the best-known ancient dinosaur graveyards in the world where the remains of 44 Allosaurus specimens lay entombed. Victims of a predator trap, the Allosaurus specimens from this Quarry are some of the actors in an epic prehistoric tragedy that unfolded 150 million years ago; this is the tale of that fateful day.

Image Credit: Allosaurus skeleton from the Cleveland-Lloyd Quarry.

Cleveland-Lloyd Quarry:

Before we can understand this epic tale and the part that Allosuaurs plays, we must look at the stage where this drama unfolds. The Cleveland-Lloyd Dinosaur Quarry well known for containing the densest concentration of Jurassic dinosaur fossils ever found, is a paleontological site located near Cleveland, Utah in the San Rafael Swell, a part of the geological layers known as the Morrison Formation.

Morrison Formation:

Image Credit: Morrison Formation in Utah

The Morrison Formation is a distinctive sequence of Upper Jurassic sedimentary rock found in the western United States, which has been the most fertile source of dinosaur fossils in North America and covers an area of 600,000 square miles. Composed of mudstone, sandstone, siltstone, and limestone with a light gray, greenish, and red sediment, the Morrison Formation was a Jurassic waterway shortly after Lauraisa split into the continents of North America and Eurasia.

Image Credit: Map of the continents 150 million years ago during the Jurassic Period.

As North America moved north and passed through the subtropical regions, the deposits from drainage basins carried by streams and rivers became the Morrison Formation. Above is a map of the Earth as the contents traversed the globe due to plate tectonics.

Image Credit: Cleveland-Lloyd Quarry map of Jurassic Dinosaurs bones.

Above is a map of all the dinosaur bones found preserved within the Cleveland-Lloyd Quarry. Looking at this grapic two things are abundantly clear.

First, the amount of carnivores present at the Cleveland-Lloyd Quarry is staggering. Indicated in green, the theropods present are predominately Allosaurus. Accompanying Allosaurus are the remains of Ceratosaurus (SERR-at-oh-SORE-us) – the most dragon like-dinosaur known and relative of Abelisaurus, Stokesaurus – the first tyrannosauroids and primitive ancestor of Tyrannosaurus Rex, Mashosaurus (MARSH-o-SORE-us), Torvosaurus (TORE-voh-SORE-us) the biggest carnivore of its time – as big as Allosaurs and heavier too, and Tanycolagreus – a primitive coelurosaurian theropod.

Second, the herbivores present are fewer but noteworthy. In yellow are the remains of several massive sauropods, Camarasaurus (CAM-a-ra-SORE-us) – 25.4 tons and Brontosaurus Excelsus (BRONT-oh-SORE-us) – 18 tons. Denoted in blue are the remains of an Ornithopod Camptosaurus (CAMP-toe-SORE-us), and indicated in red are the remains of several Thyreophora or armored dinosaurs known as Stegosaurus.

Image Credit: A Barosaurus defending itself against a pair of Allosaurus Thereopods.

Upon looking at the remains encompassing a wide variety of different dinosaurs, it is clear that something unusual attracted the assemblage of paleofauna to this location. Carnivores outnumbering herbivores points to scenes in which predators flocked to the site. What drew the diverse number of theropods to this site 150 million years ago? This Jurassic crime scene preserved in stone – the Cleveland-LLoyd Quarry – is a predator trap.

What is a Predator Trap? How Does it work?

predator trap results from a natural hazard where prey animals become trapped or incapacitated, and the predators attracted to the struggling prey suffer the same fate. As more and more animals become ensnared in the trap, additional predators and scavenges become attracted to this mounting accumulation of carrion until a wide variety of animals are tragically caught and killed by the natural hazard. The predator trap can appear many times, accumulating countless victims over millions of years.

Unlike the dry landscape today, 150 million years ago, the Cleveland-Lloyd Quarry was a freshwater lake, a source of water that drew many dinosaurs to its shores. Much like Africa today, this area had wet and dry seasons. The wet seasons, with torrential rains and floods, would fill the landscape with water. As the dry season approached, the water would dry up; dense mud would then take the place of the water. It is this weather cycle that sets the stage for what happens next.

How did the Cleveland-Lloyd Quarry Drama Unfold?

While it’s impossible to say exactly how the events unfolded at the Cleveland-Lloyd Quarry 150 million year ago, fossil evidence suggests a probable interpretation of that fateful day. Brad Cypy. (2014, July 13) Jurassic Fight Club: Bloodies Battle {Video File}. YouTube

Cleveland-Lloyd Quarry. 9:00 am – Act 1; Scene 1. Adult Stegosaurus and Offspring Enters, Stage Right.

Image Credit: Stegosaurus

A Stegosaurus and her young searching for water approach the shrinking lake bed. The hardened upper crust buckles under their massive weight, causing their feet to sink into the soft muck below and become affixed. The cries of distress from the Stegosaurus pair attract a lone carnivore, Ceratosaurus (SERR-at-oh-SORE-us).

Cleveland-Lloyd Quarry. 9:30 am. – Act 1; Scene 2. Ceratosaurus Enters Stage Left.

Image Credit: Ceratosaurus

The fossil record shows that a lone Ceratosaurus was the first to arrive at the scene at Cleveland-Lloyd Quarry. One of the rarest killers, Ceratosaurus, is 13 feet tall, 20 feet from snout to tail, and weighs 3,000 pounds, a mid-size predator in the Late Jurassic. Ceratosaurus may not have been massive, but his oversized teeth that worked like a meat slicer made him a fearsome beast. (Pim, 2019)

Ceratosaurus underneath a Stegosaurus. National Museum of Natural History. Washington, D.C.

Ceratosaurus has the most wicked teeth of any predator that walked the Earth because he has two different kinds of teeth, a trait rare in theropods. The upper teeth were long and blade-like, and the lower teeth were conical and more powerful. Ceratosaurs would use the lower jaws to grab ahold of flesh and bring down the top teeth like a meat slicer cutting a chunk out of his prey. Ceratosaurus’s bite allowed him to compensate for two weaknesses: diminished forearm claws and smaller leg muscles, reducing speed and agility. Not equipped for battle, Ceratosaurus is made to slash and dash. Dinosaurs: The Complete, Up-To-Date Encyclopedia. (Holtz & Rey. 2007).

Observing the Stegosaur pair trapped in the mire, Ceratosaurus attacks the smaller Stegosaurus. Taking massive chunks out of the struggling Stegosaurus pair.

Cleveland-Lloyd Quarry. 10:00 am. – Act 1; Scene 3. A small group of Allosaurus Approach the Lakebed. Center Stage.

The most common dinosaur found at the Cleveland-Lloyd Quarry site is Allsoaurus. Allosaurus predates Tyrannosaurus Rex by 80 million years and is the first giant theropod to roam North America.

Image Credit: Allosaurus Attacking Stegosaurus Pair.

The name Allosaurus means “Other Reptile”. At its time, there was nothing as fearsome as Allosaurus. The first of the giant meat-eating dinosaurs, this carnivore was Tyrannosaurus Rex before there was Tyrannosaurus Rex. Possessing a rare trait in theropods, Allosaurus had “Freddie Krueger” like hands with three fingers armed with a long, sharp sickle claw used to slash and tear flesh. 13 feet tall, 40 feet from snout to tail, and weighing up to 8,000 pounds (4 tons), Allosaurus is the butcher of the Jurassic. (Pim, 2019).

Allosaurus, equipped to take on big game hunted sauropods, some of the largest animals the planet has ever seen during the Late Jurassic. A long, rigid tail provided excellent balance. Coupled with massive leg muscles, Allosaurus is a powerful, fast runner with incredible agility. Dinosaurs: The Most Complete Up-To-Date Encyclopedia (Holtz & Rey, 2007).

Image Credit: Endocast of Allosaurus Brain

Endocasts of the Allosaurus brain reveal that in addition to being the first giant theropod, Allosaurus was also the smartest carnivore in the Late Jurassic. Allosaurus was capable of advanced social behaviors such as cooperative hunting and planning. Like modern-day birds, Allosaurus was very social and lived in small groups.

A roaming group of Allosaurus arrive at the dried lake bed, attracted by the sound of disruption and the smell of fresh blood. The Allosaurus see the Stegosaurus pair stuck in the thick mire and a single Ceratosaurus. The fossil record shows that a single Ceratosaurus was present at the Cleveland-Lloyd Quarry, its bones crushed by another dinosaur.

Cleveland-Lloyd Quarry. 10:30 am – Act 1; Scene 4. The Allosaurus Kill the Ceratosaurus and feed on the Stegosaurus Pair.

Attempting to defend its meal against the Allosaurus group, the Ceratosaurus has an altercation with the Allosaurus. Small and not robust like the much more derived Allosaurus, the Ceratosaurus is out-competed, crushed, and killed by better-equipped theropods.

Splade toes allow the theropods to walk on top of the hardened crust of the dried lake bed without sinking into the muck below. Circling the herbivores, the Allosaurus group continues to feed on the larger struggling Stegosaurus. Armed with plates along its back and spikes at the end of its tail, the Stegosaurus uses all its defenses to the best of its ability. The fossil records show that one of the Allosaurus has pathologies indicative of a Stegosaur strike by the spikes on its tail. The other Allosaurus, underestimating the Stegosaurus’s ability, takes a step back when another group of dinosaurs enters the scene.

Splayed toes of theropods allow them to distribute their weight over larger areas.

Cleveland-Lloyd Quarry. 11:00 am. – Act 2; Scene 1. Camarasaurus Herd Enter, Stage Left.

Image Credit: Camarasaurus Herd

Traversing the Jurassic landscape on yearly migrations, a traveling herd of Camarasaurus severely parched arrived at the water source. Due to the ongoing drought resulting from the dry season, the much-needed water had transitioned to a thick, soupy mud. Motivated by desperate thirst, the Camarasaurus herd approached the moist, thick muck.

Witnessing the unfolding bloody scene, driven by intense thirst, the leading Camasasaurus cautiously approaches the dried lake bed. Victim of his weight, the Camasaurus breaks through the hardened top layer and becomes entrapped by its weight, and the 25-ton Camarasaurus’s feet sink deep into the silt. Unable to free its feet, the Camarasaurus cried in distress. The Allosaurus, determining that attacking the Stegosaurus is too risky, sees the Camarasaurus as an easier target and approaches the struggling titan.

Unable to free its feet, the Camarasaurus cried in distress. Another group of nearby Allosaurus heard the cries of anguish and approached the scene. Upon observing the entrapped Sauropod, the carnivores assumed a free meal was at hand, hot-footed toward the struggling prey.

Cleveland-Lloyd Quarry. 11:30 am. – Act 2; Scene 2. The Noise, Smell of Blood, and Carnage Attract More Predators.

Adding to the chorus of distressing calls of anguish, the entrapped herbivores, and battling carnivores attract more predators to the scene.

The fossil record of this event shows that under the feet of the Camarasaurus lies the crushed body of an Allosaurus. At some point during the struggle, the Camarasaurus freed its front legs and reared up on its hind legs, crushing an Allosaurus running towards it.

More carnivores arrive, attracted by the carnage as the battle rages. Allosaurus, the most common animal at this site, fought and killed each other as they competed for the carcasses. As more carnivores became trapped in the thick mire, the predator trap claimed more victims. The noise at Cleveland-Lloyd Quarry on this day 150 million years ago would have been deafening. It is evident from the events recorded in stone that the land flowed with blood.

~ End Scene ~

Image Credit: Carnivores Fighting Over Carrion at Clevenland-Lloyd Quarry.

This Jurassic crime scene is a resource for dinosaur bones and allows us to understand how these animals relate to each other. The largest dinosaur graveyard, Cleveland-Lloyd Quarry, is still revealing its secrets.

I am a multi-disciplinary writer, blogger, and web content creator. Please visit my writing portfolio and other blogs if you like this post.

The Works Of Noelle K. Moser – Writing Portfolio

The Kuntry Klucker – A blog about keeping backyard chickens.

Chicken Math University – A blog about homeschooling

~ Noelle K. Moser ~

Allosaurus and I. National Museum of Natural History in Washington, D.C.

Resources:

Holtz, Thomas. R. Jr. & Rey, Luis V. Dinosaurs. The Most Complete, Up-To-Date Encyclopedia. New York, Random House, 2007.

Pim, Keiron & Pastori, Fabio. Dinosaurs The Grand Tour. New York, The Experiment, 2019.

Ransom-Johnson, Evan & Csotonyi, Julius. Dinosaur World. Kennebunkport, Maine, Applesauce Press, 2023

The Evolution of Tyrannosaurus Rex: From Triassic Origins to Cretaceous Dominance

email: noellemoser@charter.net

Tyrannosaurus Rex: National Museum of Natural History. Washington, D.C

Since its discovery in the summer of 1902 by Barnum Brown, no other dinosaur has captured the human imagination quite like the Tyrannosaurus Rex. Upon its discovery, Barnum Brown wrote this to Henry Fairfield Osborn, friend, and curator of the American Museum of Natural History in New York. “It is as if a child’s conception of a monster had become real and was laid down in stone” (Kindall,2022). Though most of the skull and tail were missing, everything about this monster would overwhelm the human imagination.

The specimen that Brown found stood 13 feet tall at the hips, its jaws measured over 4 ft in length and would have weighed 6-8 tons. This was the only known specimen to science as was given the appropriate name Tyrannosaurus Rex by Henry Osborne in the fall of 1902. Tyrannosaurus which means “tyrant lizard” in Greek and “rex” which means “king” in Latin; Tyrannosaurus Rex, the king of the lizards, no other name would capture in two words the sheer power contained within this beast.

Who was this creature? What was the nature of this tyrant lizard? Without the restless adventuring spirit of Barnum Brown who unearthed the first T-Rex and captivated the imagination of people everywhere, dinosaurs would have remained nothing more than a novelty never inspiring people to devote the necessary resources and energy to understand this creature and the world in which it lived.

Without Tyrannosaurus Rex to grace museum halls, only herbivores would represent the giants of the Mesozoic. Without Tyrannosaurus Rex there would be no Jurassic Park, no dinosaur toys, no children in dinosaur pajamas, and no creature to stand at the intersections of popular culture and modern science.

Without T-Rex, our world would look very different, and our understanding of the past would be incomplete. The discovery of Tyrannosaurus Rex did more than draw the public to Natural History Museums, Tyrannosaurus Rex started a revolution in understanding our world. In this post, we will reach out with our imagination and touch the bones of this incredible creature from another time and place.

Image Credit: Noelle K. Moser. Tyrannosaurus Rex MOR 555 biting down on a Triceratops. National Museum of Natural History, Washington, D.C.

Tyrannosaurus Rex was the ultimate predator, the largest and deadliest animal to walk the earth. Ruling the American Midwest for millions of years, Tyrannosaurus Rex brought down massive, armored prey Triceratops and Inkeylosaurs tanks of the Cretaceous.

At an average of 40 feet long, 18 feet tall, and weighing 6-8 tons, Tyrannosaurus rex was a mouth on legs, the butcher of the Cretaceous. The skull of T-rex is the most impressive anti-tank weapon evolution ever produced. The jaws of this theropod are infamous, 5 feet long, and filled with 60 piercing and bone-crushing teeth with a bite force 16 times stronger than an alligator. Constructed of 64 bones, the skull, and attached 2 ft thick neck muscles could lift a hippo. Counterbalancing the massive skull is a tail weighing a ton combined with a pelvis and legs that anchor and account for half of the T-rex’s weight.

Image Credit: Noelle K. Moser. Me peering through the fenestrae of Tyrannosaurus Rex MOR 555. The conical serrated teeth of T-rex were the most impressive anti-tank weapon that evolution ever created. Cincinnati Natural History Museum. Cincinnati, Ohio.

Ironically, the teeth of Tyrannosaurus Rex are the bluntest of all the Tyrannosauroid family, meaning that the oral weaponry of this colossal theropod was for bone crushing which brings into question adaptions for scavenging. It is clear from the braincase of Tyrannosaurus skulls that the olfactory region is prominent, indicating that the T-Rex had superb smelling capabilities that aided in sniffing out carcasses or kills from other carnivores. Contrary to Jurassic Park, Tyrannosaurus Rex could detect even the slightest movement. At 16 inches apart and 18 feet high, the eyes of T-Rex possessed stereoscopic binocular vision and could discern fine detail at a distance of 4 miles, six times further than a human with 20/20 vision. The human eye requires the aid of binoculars to see details at this distance.

If impeccable vision and olfactory senses were not enough, brain case studies of Tyrannosaurus show that this apex predator could hear sounds below 40 Hz at great distances. While unable to discern the chirps of birds or the buzz of insects, T-Rex could perceive the low grunt of a distant meal or the low-frequency call of a potential mate.

If T-Rex could hear low-register sounds, it stands to reason that it could produce low-register sounds. Contrary to Cinema, Tyrannosaurus Rex could not roar as often depicted in dinosaur thrillers. However, in the absence of a roar, Tyrannosaurus vocalizations would be felt as vibrations. The human ear is unable to discern sounds below 20 Hz, but we can perceive vibrations produced by sounds below this audible register. While unable to hear the vocalizations of the approaching T-Rex, we could sense the vibrations produced like rolls of distant thunder.

While not as dramatic as cinema depictions of encounters, the experience of an ever-increasing vibration as the Tyrannosaurus Rex approached in the dark of night in a wooded environment would be terrifying. 150 million years in the making, Tyrannosaurus Rex is the ultimate apex creature of evolution.

Image Credit: Noelle K. Moser. Tryrannosaurus Rex MOR 555 tail. The tail of T-rex weighed a ton to counterbalance the large 5-foot skull. National Museum of Natural History. Washington, D.C.

To fully comprehend Tyrannosaurus Rex, it’s essential to delve into its beginnings. As the apex predator of the late Cretaceous period, Tyrannosaurus Rex represented the culmination of evolution’s largest carnivores. The adaptations that occurred within the T-rex lineage gave rise to this remarkable beast. The reasons behind the Tyrannosaurus’ diminutive arms and its colossal skull are embedded in its evolutionary journey, beginning with the Permian Extinction that marked the advent of the first dinosaurs.

Tyrannosaurs began 100 million years ago and like all dinosaurs, they started as small, underdogs living in the shadows of the other apex predators at the beginning of the Triassic, behemoths such as postosuchus apex archosaur, and other carnivores of the Triassic.

240-230 million years ago, dinosaurs like Herrerasaurus and Eoraptor evolved from their cat-size dinosaurmoprhs ancestors when the earth hosted the once giant supercontinent Pangea. Although one united land mass, Pangea was a challenging environment for primitive dinosaurs to both live and evolve.

Dryland extended from pole to pole, but on the other side was an open ocean-Panthalassa. Because currents could travel from the equator to the poles without interference, low latitudes were warm preventing ice caps from forming. The Arctic and Antarctic were tropical with summer temperatures a temperate 70 to 80 degrees year-round and winter temperatures barely below freezing.

Because Pangea was centered on the equator, and the other half was cooling down in the winter, this land orientation caused violent air currents to traverse the supercontinent. These air masses triggered megamonsoons, bringing torrential downpours to the land mass, and causing flooding and deadly storms. (Brusatte, 2018)

The global megamonsoons divided Pangea into regions based on varying amounts of precipitation, winds, and temperatures. Within this landmass were the mid-latitudes. These regions were cooler with a moist and wet climate that was hospitable to life. Here Herrerasaurus, Eroraptor, and other dinosaurs lived and thrived. Pangea with its extreme weather and dangerous unpredictability was the evolutionary stage set out for the dinosaurs. From the ashes left by the Permian Extinction, dinosaurs evolved in this harsh world with many challenges but they weren’t alone.

Herrerasaurus: Image Credit

Evolving alongside the dinosaurs were other creatures that were larger and stronger. One of these adversaries was the metopsoaurus a giant amphibian. Metoposaurus was a monster with a head the size of a coffee table and jaws with hundreds of piercing teeth. Metospsoaurus was the ancestor of today’s frogs, toads, newts, and salamanders and it dominated the shore regions of many of Pangea’s lakes and rivers, particularly in the midlatitude humid belts.

Small primitive dinosaurs such as Eoraptor were on the menu and had to approach the shore regions with great caution. Dicynodont, a therapsid, pig-like mammal that ate roots, leaves, and insects completed with the primitive dinosaurs for food and habitat. Saurosuchus a crocodile cousin and mighty apex predator and one of the largest Rauisuchians was a tyrant forcing the dinosaurs into their role as underdogs in the ecosystem.

When life in Triassic Pangea seemed bleak and antagonistic towards the primitive dinosaurs, two important things happened that gave them an edge.

First, the humid belt region that was dominated by the rhynchosaurus and dicynodonts began to see their numbers decrease and finally disappear. (Brusatte, 2018). It’s not understood why these creatures’ faced extinction, but the effect was in the dinosaur’s favor. The niches vacated by these large herbivores gave the primitive sauropod dinosaurs such as Panphagia and Saturnalia a new and abundant food source. Plateosaurus, a well-documented primitive sauropod thrived 225-215 million years ago during this time.

Second, around 215 million years ago, the first dinosaurs began inhabiting the subtropical arid regions of the Northern Hemisphere, now the American Southwest (Brusatte, 2018). It is thought that climate change and monsoon patterns made these regions more tolerable, allowing the dinosaurs access to these once-arid regions.

Plateosaurus: Image Credit

Among these primitive dinosaurs that exploited the newly unoccupied and available food sources and once arid regions of Pangea was Coelophysis. A dog-size, lightweight, fast-running, sharp-toothed Triassic dinosaur who was the earliest member of a theropod dynasty that would one day produce Velociraptors, Birds, and Tyrannosaurus Rex-the largest carnivore to ever walk the Earth (Brusatte, 2018). This is where the story of T-rex began, the humblest of beginnings in the Triassic arid regions of Pangea.

Coelophysis: Image Credit

Coelophysis was first discovered in 1889 from a massive bone bed found on Ghost Ranch in New Mexico. During the bone wars (a fierce rivalry between Edward Drinker Cope and Othniel Charles March) these men discovered a vast number of dinosaur specimens naming many of the most well-loved dinosaurs throughout their rivalry. It was Cope who later named Coelophysis in 1889. The Ghost Ranch bone bed dates back to 220 million years ago when a Triasic megamoonson flood overtook a herd of Coelophysis and buried them so rapidly that their bodies were protected and fossilized in the sediment.

As the Triassic continued, the primitive dinosaurs along with the dominant archosaurs evolved, multiplied, and occupied more regions of the Pangea supercontinent. The dinosaurs continued to diversify and thrive as they occupied vacant niches left by the waning populations of dicynodonts and some Rauisuchian species. Then about 201 million years ago, the earth began to rumble. Miles below the surface, plate tectonics, the engine that drives the continents came to life.

The supercontinent Pangea began to split, and North America separated from Europe and Africa. The Atlantic Ocean occupies the region that these continents once claimed. But before the continental divorce was finalized, the Earth hemorrhaged lava unlike anything today. Massive volcanic eruptions raged for 600,000 years, and megavolcanoes erupted along what is the Atlantic Seaboard today.

Unlike vulcanism today, these mega volcanoes erupted in four violent pulses siring the edges of the continents, followed by the flood basalts of the Central Atlantic Magmatic Providence (CAMP). CAMP is a milestone in Earth’s history, a gravestone, and the cause of the Triassic Extinction. CAMP is the largest igneous province in the solar system, an estimated 11 million kilometers, and the eruptions belched tidal waves of lava and flames similar to the Siberian Traps.

Waves of lava flowed across the land, incinerating everything in the path. Like the Permian Extinction, massive amounts of carbon dioxide and sulfur dioxide were released into the atmosphere causing intense global warming followed by cooling. The oceans acidified due to the temperature flotations, starving the waters of oxygen and triggering an ecosystem collapse on land and in the water. An estimated 30 percent of species died, including all archosauromorphs, crocodylomorphs, pterosaurs, and some dinosaurs. Other groups that died out were aetosaurs, phytosaurs, and rauiuschids. After the dust settled and the volcanoes subsided, the dinosaurs became great survivors of the global meltdown.

As Pangea unzipped, the earth hemorrhaged lava: Image Credit

Once underdogs, dinosaurs were compelled to remain diminutive alongside the larger and more dominant archosauromorphs, crocodylomorphs, and pterosaurs. However, following the breakup of the Pangea supercontinent, they thrived. As inheritors of the Earth and a newfound dominant force, dinosaurs grew significantly larger, marking the advent of the Age of Dinosaurs and the era of the Jurassic Giants.

In dinosaur evolution, there are two major clades of Dinosauria categorized by a forward or backward-facing pubis bone. Saurichians (“lizard-hipped”) dinosaurs have a forward-pointing pubis and (Ornithischians (“bird-hipped”) dinosaurs have a backward-facing pubis bone.

Saurischia contains all theropod and sauropod dinosaurs. Ornithiscia contains armored and horned dinosaurs such as Triceratops, Ankylosaurus, and all Hadrosaurs such as Edmontosaurus. Another distinguishing feature is that Saurinchia possesses air sacs, spaces within the bones that make the skeletons lighter. It is, for this reason, that titanosaurs could raise their long necks and birds can achieve flight by efficiently utilizing oxygen in their bodies.

Forward Facing Pubis of Tyrannosaurus Rex: Image Credit
Backward-facing Pubis Bone of Edmontosaurus (Hadrosaur): Image Credit

Tyrannosaurus Rex, is a tyrannosaur, a clade of theropod tyrant dinosaurs. Once thought that Tyrannosaurs were descendants of Allosaurus, a member of a Carcharodontosauroid clade that produced the largest theropod to ever walk the earth, Giganotosaurus. However, physical characteristics in the skulls, hips, forelimbs, and hindlimbs separated the tyrant dinosaurs from this carnosaur group.

Tyrannosaurs have large skulls relative to body size, solid roofs in their mouth which increased their lethal bite, blunt snouts, eyes aimed forward producing stereoscopic vision, and scraper teeth in the front of their upper jaws, a trait unique to tyrannosaurs. Then in 2004, a little dinosaur from the Early Cretaceous was found in Chona’s Yixian Formation.

Dilong, early Tyrannosauroid directly related to Coelurosaurs. Image Credit

Dilong, a little theropod no more than 5 feet long looked like a much earlier Coelurosaur with a few traits that are only found in Tyrannosaurs – a large skull for body size, a blunt snout, and little scraper teeth in the front of its jaws useful for nipping and scraping meat from bones. The discovery of this little dinosaur removed Tyrannosaurus as a distant relative of Allosaurus and placed T-Rex in Coelurosauria, a clade of theropod dinosaurs directly related to birds. T-Rex is no longer considered a Carcharodontosauroid but rather an overgrown Coelurosaur or giant chicken.

Then in 2010, a smaller dinosaur was discovered in Siberia. Kileskus is the oldest tyrannosaur found in rocks dating back to about 170 million years ago, firmly in the middle part of the Jurassic. This new tyrannosaur was small, 7 feet long, a few feet tall, and weighed less than 100 pounds with large nostrils and sinuses and a solid roof, many of the characteristics seen in Tyrannosaurus Rex. 

Kileskus: Image Credit

Kileskus and Guanlong (another tyrannosaur) were about the same size and had similar tyrannosaur characteristics, three-fingered hands, and head crests utilized for show. These primitive tyrannosaurs are a good picture of how the early tyrannosaur clade looked and behaved. While nowhere near the likeness of T-Rex, these small tyrannosaurs thrived in their ecosystem hunting bugs, small mammals, and other small things they could catch. They were fast, had sharp teeth, and feared Sinraptor and Monolophosaurus, cousins of Allosaurus, the large apex carcharodontosaur carnivores of the time.

Kileskus linked to an earlier discovery in 2009 that firmly locked another tyrannosaur puzzle piece into place. Sinotyrannus, a large tyrannosaur measuring 30–33 ft and weighing 2.5 metric tons was the oldest large basal tyrannosaur known. This discovery proved that tyrannosaurs gradually increased in size throughout the Jurassic and Early Cretaceous.

In 2012 the most remarkable tyrannosaur discovery was announced. A nearly complete skeleton of a new dinosaur found in China dating to 125 million years ago with protofeathers, Yutyrannus. Yuthrannus (YOO-tie-RAN-us), a coelurosaur- the theropod clade that contains T-Rex and birds-raised the prospect that coelurosaurs had feathered including the most famous tyrannosaur, Tyrannosaurus Rex.

Yutyrannus: Image Credit

Knowing T-Rex’s origin is only part of the question, the other question to answer is how did Tyrannosaurus Rex become so big. Not a lot is known about this period, the fossil record has yet to yield those secrets. What we do know is that about 94 million years ago the climate began to change. Temperatures spiked and sea levels oscillated and acidification starved the oceans of oxygen. Similar to the Permian Extinction but not as severe. During this time the large theropods of the time the carcharodontosaurs and spinosaurs died off leaving a niche that the tyrannosaurs filled. Tyrannosaurus Rex the remaining tyrannosaur responded by growing larger and starting the reign as the Tyrant King.

T-Rex’s small arms are a defining trait of this famous theropod, where did they come from? T-Rex is not the only dinosaur to have small arms, many theropods have small arms compared to the size of their bodies. There have been many theories presented to explain the evolutionary adaption of small arms, from protection during group feeding to the reduction of harm when fighting over mates or territory. The most likely scenario comes from a paper published in Acta Palaeontologica Polonica, suggesting that instead of the arms shrinking, theropods simply outgrew their arms making them appear smaller compared to body size.

Argentinaosaurus (Titanosaur) and Giganatosaurus (Thereopod); Image Credit

During the Jurassic, an arms race took place between herbivores and carnivores. As the herbivores increased in size, so did the carnivores. The giants of the Jurassic were the Titanosaurs, the largest land animals ever recorded in Earth’s history roamed from place to place in search of food. The large carnivores of that time, Allosaurus and Giganotosaurus stalked the herds of Titanosaurus as they marched across the land in yearly migrations.

To take on one of these giants, theropods had to be large. Becoming large is calorically expensive and traits not necessary for survival are not selected. In the case of theropods, as their bodies and skulls became larger, arms did not follow suit. Evolution selected large jaws with powerful muscles yielding a lethal bite over arms in the arms race between herbivores and carnivores. By the time T-Rex arrived on the scene in the Cretaceous, arms were all but useless with evolution favoring the large boxy skulls with jaws full of 6-inch serrated steak knife teeth as the preferred mode of survival.

As the Jurassic yielded to the Cretaceous period, the large theropods that competed with the Tyrannosaurs died out. Ceratosaurus, Allosaurus, and Torvosaurus were gone by the beginning of the Cretaceous. Moving into the Cretaceous were two main theropod clades, Carcharodontosauria represented by Giganotosaurus (Southern Hemisphere), Tyrannosaurs represented by Abelisaurus (Southern Hemisphere), and Tyrannosaurus Rex (North Hemisphere).

These clades of theropods once roamed, preying on herds of herbivores and hadrosaurs across various regions. Around 90 million years ago, the Giganotosaurus, a representative of the Carcharodontosaurs, was outcompeted by tyrannosaurs, leading to its extinction. This event left the tyrannosaurs to dominate. Throughout the Late Cretaceous period, the Tyrannosaurus Rex stood as the apex predator, known as the ‘King of the Lizards,’ until the Cretaceous-Paleogene extinction event 66 million years ago, which marked the end of the dinosaur era.

Tyrannosaurus Rex was the apex predator of all time, the pillar of evolution. From the humblest of beginnings in the once arid regions of Pangea embodied in Coelophysis to the King of the Lizards, T-rex was a feat of evolution produced by millions upon millions of years of adaptions that created the most iconic creature of the Mesozoic.

It seems as if Tyrannosaurus Rex was unstoppable, with nothing to fear or almost nothing. 66 million years ago T-Rex witnessed one of the worst days the world has ever seen. A rock 6 miles wide fell out of the sky smashing into the earth with unimaginable force bringing the reign of T-Rex and the Age of the Dinosaurs to a close. For 66 million years Tyrannosaurus Rex lay entombed in the sedimentary rock of the Hell Creek Formation in the American Midwest, exposed for the first time in 1902 by Barnum Brown, and changed our world forever.

No other creature has inspired the human imagination quite like Tyrannosaurus Rex. Since its discovery, T-Rex stands at the intersection between popular culture and modern science inspiring countless people, paleontologists, and dinosaur enthusiasts like myself to understand the world from which it lived.

Tyrannosaurus changed our world in ways we may not realize. Without T-Rex, there would be no Godzilla, no dinosaur toys, no children in dinosaur pajamas, no Jurassic Park or Jurassic World, no inflatable dinosaur costumes, no creature to grace museum halls, and no counterpart to the countless herbivores from the Mesozoic.

Without T-Rex our understanding of the Mesozoic would be incomplete, our heritage starting from cynodonts to primates would look very different, and we would look very different. T-Rex forced our rat-like ancestors to remain small, living under the feet of the dinosaurs in burrows or above their heads in the canopy.

Without the T-Rex, the course of our evolution would have been altered significantly. It’s evident that we, as humans, owe our existence to the random asteroid that struck Earth 66 million years ago, triggering the mass extinction event that ended the reign of the dinosaurs.

But life is resilient, our mammal ancestors rose out of the ashes left by T-Rex just like Coelophysis rose out of the ashes of the Permian. T-Rex’s story is our story, and our story can only begin when their story ends.

Our story begins because their story ends. ~ Noelle K. Moser ~ Sketched by me.

Barnum Brown’s T-Rex still stands on the fourth floor in Manhattan, New York surrounded by the sounds of one of North America’s largest cities. Visitors look up and gaze at the largest carnivore to ever walk the earth 66 million years ago. Frozen in time, Tyrannosaurus Rex is the witness of a world that we will never see but can only experience through bone.

Tyrannosaurus Rex found by Barnum Brown. American Museum of National History. New York, New York. Image Credit

I regret that I will never see a living Tyrannosaurus Rex, my closest encounters will be standing at the feet of these amazing creatures, looking up, reaching out, and touching bone. The only link I have to their world is through my backyard chickens, in their veins pump the blood of dinosaurs as they are coelurosaurs and directly related to the mighty T-Rex.

I observe in their behavior the majesty that T-Rex possessed and can imagine how he walked and sounded. The crow of my roosters is a sound from another world, an ancient world that I will never see. But it is clear, that if Tyrannosaurus Rex had not perished in that chance asteroid impact, I would not be here.

He stands as a testament and witness to that earth-shattering day. I am here because my small rat-like ancestors rose out of the ashes of the dinosaurs and ushered in the age of mammals.

If you like this post, please subscribe.

I am a multi-disciplinary writer, blogger, and content creator. If you like my work, please visit my Writing Portfolio.

Resources:

Brusatte, Steve. The Rise and Fall of the Dinosaurs: A New History of Their Lost World.New York: HarperCollins Publishers, 2018

Randall, David K. The Monster’s Bones the Discovery of the T. Rex and How It Shook Our World. New York: W.W Norton & Company, 2002.

My visit to Natural History Museums across the Nation.

Tyrannosaurus Rex, MOR 555 and I. National Museum of Natural History Washington, D.C. (August 2022)

Theropod Evolution: Unveiling Meraxes Gigas, the Late Cretaceous Giant

Image Credit: Meraxes Gigas.

We have a new dinosaur! A theropod with short limbs like Tyrannosaurus Rex. Tyrannosaurus is not the only famous giant carnivorous dinosaur; meet Meraxes Gigas.

During the summer of 2022, researchers uncovered a previously unknown dinosaur from the Late Cretaceous, Meraxes Gigas. Meraxes belongs to the genus carcharodontosaurid theropods. The name, “Meraxes”, honors a dragon from the George R. R. Martin novel, A Song of Ice and Fire – Wikipedia The specific name, “Gigas”, derived from the Greek word meaning “giant”, in reference to the theropod’s large size.

Found in the Huincul Formation of Argentine Patagonia was a nearly complete skeleton. Meraxes Gigas is of pivotal importance because this discovery constitute a complete skull, partial forelimbs, complete hindlimbs, fragmentary ribs, and cervical and complete caudal vertebrae. 

The hand of theropods is imperative to determine whether the specimen is primitive or derived. Primitive in dinosaur terminology means an early stage in evolutionary development. Derived means most recent in dinosaurian evolution. To help this make sense, Coelophysis is a primitive ancestor of the derived Tyrannosaurus Rex.

Image Credit: Gignotosaurus skeleton, notice the longer arms and three digits on each hand. Giganotosaurus is more derived than the primitive theropod Coelophysis.

Primitive theropod dinosaurs have longer arms and digital formula I-IV. Derived theropods will have shorter arms and a reduced number of digits.

Image Credit: Coelophysis primitive theropod dinosaur. Notice that Ceolophysis has longer arms and 4 digits on each hand.

Coelophysis, the oldest known theropod, defined as a primitive Late Triassic theropod had longer arms and 4 digits on each hand.

Image Credit: Allosaurus

Allosaurus, more derived lived during the Middle-Late Jurassic and possess shorter arms and only three digits on each hand. Tyrannosaurus the Cretaceous apex predator had very short arms and only 2 digits on each hand.

Image Credit: Noelle K. Moser. Walter, Tyrannosaurus Rex located in Washington, D.C. has very short arms and only 2 digits on each hand.

As observed by these images, the skull, forearms, hands, and digits are gold in theropod discoveries. The hands of theropod dinosaurs tell us so much about the evolution of dinosaurs during the Mesozoic.

In addition to the forearms and digits, complete or near complete skulls found in new dinosaurs’ discoveries help us understand more about the creatures.

At first glance, the skulls of these giant theropods appear similar; massive jaws with numerous long serrated teeth. To the trained eye, the skulls of Giganotosaurus and Tyrannosaurus Rex are remarkably different.

Giganotosaurus has a long narrow skull that comes to a sharp point. The skull of Tyrannosaurus Rex is boxier and comes to a lateral line rather than a point. See the images below.

Another example of primitive and derived evolution is theropods, Allosaurus, Ceratosaurus, and, Tyrannosaurus. See the images below.

While these three theropods appear similar, Allosaurus and contemporary Ceratosaurus predate Tyrannosaurus by 80 million years.

Head Creasts:

Another feature present in theropod dinosaurs, specifically primitive species, is that of head crests. Many Late Triassic and Early Jurassic theropod species possessed head crests. It is thought that these crests were used as display features for mating and sexual dimorphism. In later derived theropod species, these crests disappear.

Image Credit:

The image above depicts Ceratosaurus nasicornis, the apex predator of the early Jurassic, displaying crests on the head can be seen. Ceratosaurus was driven to extinction by the Late Jurassic, succeeded by the more successful Allosaurus.

Image Credit:

Allosaurus, as mentioned above, is the most famous predecessor to Tyrannosaurus Rex. Living through the greater part of the Jurassic, Allosaurus was the apex predator of its time and possessed primitive features – three-digit hands, long forearms, and head crests. It is now known why derived theropods lose the head crests.

Image Credit:

By the time we traverse, the expansive amount of time between Ceratosaurus and Tyrannosaurus Rex (80 million years) head crests disappear from theropod anatomy.

Size:

In addition to reduced digits and head crests, as theropods evolve they get larger. Coelophysis at maturity was about 10 feet long and weighed 100 pounds. Compare that to the Jurassic theropod Ceraosaurus which grew to 20 feet long and weighed about 2,000 pounds. Allosaurus grew to be 12 feet long and 10 feet tall weighing 2.3 metric tons. Tyrannosaurus Rex, the largest land theropod to ever live grew to 43 feet long and weighed 6-8 tons.

Meraxes Gigas:

Now, that you have a better understanding of theropod dinosaurs, let’s take another look at Meraxes gigas. Meraxes is a crucial find in the world of dinosaur studies because the remains included key anatomical features, a complete forelimb, hand, a skull, and various other bones. The most important being that of the hand and skull.

According to the research, Meraxes Gigas had tiny arms like Tyrannosaurus with three digits on each hand like Allosaurus. Tyrannosaurus and Meraxies are not related as they are separated by about 20 million years, but it does suggest that as theropods evolved larger heads, the arms shrunk, no longer useful for hunting. Regarding size, Meraxes Gigas was 36 feet long and weighed 4 tons. To put this into perspective, Meraxies is smaller than Tyrannosaurus Rex but much larger than Allosaurus. Further noted, Meraxies does not appear to have head crests.

In terms of theropod evolution, Meraxies is more derived than Allosaurus but primitive compared to Tyrannosaurus. In terms of theropod evolution, this put Meraxies Gigas living about 90 to 100 million years ago, firmly in the Late Cretaceous. Meraxes Gigas and its close relative, Giganotosaurus died out in the Late Cretaceous, succeeding their position at the top of the food chain to the tyrannosaurids, and its famous member, Tyrannosaurus Rex.

Meraxes Gigas and the newly discovered theropod dinosaur were one of the last groups of giant carnivores to walk the Earth. While we often think of Tyrannosaurus Rex as being the lone giant carnivore stalking the Cretaceous, other large theropods competed with the tyrant dinosaurs. Although Meraxes Gigas never laid witness to the meteor that would ultimately bring the reign of the dinosaurs to an end, Tyrannosaurus Rex did.

I am a multi-disciplinary writer, blogger, and web content creator. If you liked this post, chomp the subscribe button.

If you like this blog, please visit my portfolio. Writer | The Works Of Noelle Moser

As always, thanks for reading Coffee and Coelophysis. Next time, we will take an in-depth look at the most famous theropod, Tyrannosaurus Rex.

~ Noelle ~